Report PeterOliver1's Profile

Can't fall for anything if I already know what happens, genius. Look, I don't care if Eren put on an act to save his friends. I just don't like the story. Period. Maybe next time, don't DM people youtube links for an ending that's been out for years.

This dumbass really liked SnK's ending and got mad at my review, lmao

For sure. I mostly stay on reddit, don't have the patience for this sort of website.

Uma coisa é recomendar algo sabendo que existe uma grande chance da pessoa não gostar. Outra é avaliar o pacote completo da obra, levando em conta seus méritos e defeitos, com uma análise mínima tanto crítica quanto técnica. Popularidade, hype ou nota alta não substituem uma avaliação de verdade.

Sure did. Here's what happened :
You basically came at my review guns blazing, strawmanning my position from the get go and being a bit of a contemptuous ass. But it seems your criticism was the classic "you did not like it because you did not get it" shtick. A variant of, certainly, but still. My point stands.
I did get this particular point of Eren's, but I treated it not as the center of his argument, nor as a last minute reveal that contextualizes the rest, but more as a qualifier for both Eren's personality and his rationalization for his choices. This point did not make it into my review.
Anyway, thanks for coming back to the table for clarifications.

I am disappointed you didn't take the time to answer me yet. I really want to know where I've been wrong.
I've rewatched the dialogue you spoke of, once in English, once in Japanese and once in French - just to be sure. The last one was useless, I don't speak French. I couldn't find what you are saying hinted at anywhere. I even asked an AI to help me, but AI is stupid, so it didn't find either. Internet was also no help with your theory.
I'm probably not smart enough on my own, or with AI or with the net. Please help.

Please, you seem to be a smart cookie. Enlighten me. Just, tone down the contempt, "son". Smug ain't the way for a successful first contact, is it ?
Now, tell me : what did I miss, "senpai" ?

because you have not proven a single point of mine wrong. tackle them properly. or admit you can't, as the series is laughable. and you too, since every time you write something, it's either a meme or "it's popular so it must be good". do you even know how to criticise anything? seeing your review... not really.

yeah, and Code Geass has a score of 8.71 on this website(while, at best, it is not a 4/10. and mostly because of technical particularities like music and animation. the story is not even a 1/10, but 0/10), what's your point? people are too "hyped" by certain aspects of the show to look at things clearly. also, lol, "stalking", just returned a month later to find out if you wrote something on the series and if you started to think, for once. and... no. still a cl0wn.(also, you were the one that called me a "r3t4rd" in the beginning. stop pretending you are the "innocent" one here) when are you going to finally tackle the arguments properly? from the reviews and comments so far. or you can not? just admit it. i am right, and you just like the animation-music-voice acting. everything else in that series is trash.

still haven't looked into what i wrote so far on it? do you still want to have a st00pid take on this trash series? also, what a laughable "review", lol.

invite the Attack on Titan fans that have iq's in 3 digits to abandon the memories of 16-18(which, by the way, are extremely overrated. Erwin just charged head on to keep the Zeke occupied while that "superhum4n" travels to him. Bertholdt would have exhausted himself even with creating steam to hold 10-20 soldiers. no need for Armin's "sacrifice" or the "he'll see the ocean"/"that is my dream" speech. and the whole confrontation in 18 was there just for Isayama to add drama and "depth" to the main characters) and to judge the situation properly. equating Eldians to Hebrews is st00pid and disrespectful(and what clowns edits those wikipedia pages?)

it was not, at any point, "humans vs humans". the Eldians are not "humans". and again, it was about the backstories of the communities Bertholdt and the other 3-4 came from. we know they had perceptions of them being "devils"/devils(showing a history of cruelty. or maybe an "inherent trait" that makes them more cruel. or another reference to their titan powers that make them inhum4n, which the warriors probably just borrow) as Bertholdt shouted in s2 ep11 when Armin talks about Annie's torture, and that they come from certain communities outside(or maybe even inside in 1-2 cases) the wall, but we did not know the details of those. and people thought they would witness a Ben 10 Alien Force type of infiltration. or maybe Titans that took human forms for so long that they began to think of the real humans as the villains and of themselves as the innocent. or maybe the Eldians are just a 30-50-100 years long project/apocalypse that is restricted to one area of the world, as a kind of an experiment. or maybe there are other 3-walled-communities with other 1-2 million people trying to get to each other.

but what we got in 2016 was the worst kind of scenario. one done in an extremely lazy and st00pid fashion. as i said, plagiarism and false dilemma's. i don't care about "child indoctrination/child soldiers". what's the point of s4 ep 3? what reason was there for Reiner to not want to prove himself as willing to repent for Eldia's sins? or for s4 ep15? we can easily conclude Zeke is right, even if Grisha was kinder to him. but Isayama wanted to show he "has skills" and "is able to write psychological trauma's in one's childhood" and "on brainwashing". ok, he gets a 7/10. but the context makes useless, as Zeke could arrive at that conclusion without it. also, this just proves Grisha and Grice are denialists. they did not have their memories altered like the Paradisian Eldians(they are continental Eldians), but they still ignore the Eldian crimes. millions upon millions, just because "my sister d1ed so their drive for revenge is invalid". and i know they are presented as living 80 years after and the education being influenced by human/Marleyan history manuals, but still. i feel like i am repeating myself. you should have simply just tackled the points in my review from the beginning.

i received a notification that you deleted my comment, Sherlock. and that amused me, because it was you that felt the need to come to my profile and call me a "r3t4rd". then delete only my comment(not yours also) when i asked you why you called me that or to tell me why my arguments are not valid.

it is proven as trash as it fails to properly tackle those subjects. and this can be proven, in an objective manner. yet you could not refute those points. and the fact that you try to portray this narrative as a "non-slop" is just laughable.

the audience was still "hyped" by the "humans vs titans" scenario that just unfolded in episodes 13-18(of season 3) and before, and they were not able to trully process the information in 19-22 as their brains were still "burning with fervour". your "cycle of oppression" defence is not valid either, the Eldians lose in that aspect as well. anyway, tackle point by point my review. let's see if you can actually argue. you might also defend the st00pidity of Code Geass because "it tackles imperialism and oppression", even if it does so poorly.

why are you behaving like this? you call me a "r3t4rd" and now you delete my comment? why can't you accept Attack on Titan is trash?

I am sure the industry insiders know more about AOT's position than ignorant viewers like AOT fans, lol. Dragon ball will always be more legendary and has more impact than trash like AOT. So, like I said, I will be ashamed if I was an AOT fan when a superior IP 's editor shits on it like he did,lmao.

I already saw your screenshot. It means nothing. The opinion of a Dragon Ball's editor matters more than the opinions of AOT stans. And I assure you that he is not the only one who thinks this way. AOT is just noise. Great description from him. It made noise but had no impact. The only reason it got praise early on is because of shills like Gigguck who got paid to praise it. It's fake praise. It's popular because it's shallow. Macdonald is big too. This is not an indicator of quality.